facebook twitter instagram linkedin google youtube vimeo tumblr yelp rss email podcast phone blog search brokercheck brokercheck Play Pause
The Pitfalls of Investing Overly Conservative in Retirement Thumbnail

The Pitfalls of Investing Overly Conservative in Retirement

Retirement is a significant milestone that marks the end of your working years and the beginning of a new chapter in life. As you approach this transition, you may have come across the common advice to become more conservative with your investments.

The reasoning behind this suggestion is often based on the idea that you need to protect your nest egg now that you're no longer receiving a regular paycheck. However, while this advice is well-intentioned, being overly conservative with your investments in retirement can actually lead to negative consequences.

We’ll explore into the reasons why being too conservative could be detrimental and introduce a powerful strategy known as the three-bucket retirement investment plan, which could help you achieve a worry-free retirement.


  • Being overly conservative with your investments in retirement could result in unintended drawbacks, such as not keeping pace with inflation and potentially running out of money.
  • Understanding the difference between true risks and perceived risks is crucial for making informed investment decisions that align with your retirement goals.
  • Implementing a three-bucket retirement investment plan can help you balance your short-term, mid-term, and long-term financial needs, providing a structured approach to managing your retirement assets.


When you've spent decades building your retirement savings, it's natural to want to protect your hard-earned money once you're no longer working. The fear of market volatility and the uncertainty of the future can lead many retirees to adopt an overly conservative investment approach. Let's examine some common reasons why retirees may feel inclined to become excessively conservative:

  1. "I'm retired now, so I need to focus on preserving my capital."
  2. "I can't afford to lose any money in the stock market at this stage of my life."
  3. "I want to ensure my money lasts for the rest of my life and never run out."
  4. "Since I'm retired, my investment time horizon is much shorter, so I should shift to a more conservative portfolio."

While these concerns are understandable and valid to a certain extent, they often stem from a misunderstanding of how risk works in the context of retirement investing.

In his insightful book "Simple Wealth, Inevitable Wealth," author Nick Murray emphasizes the importance of distinguishing between true risks and perceived risks, particularly from a retiree's perspective.


To make informed decisions about your retirement investments, it's essential to recognize the difference between true risks and perceived risks. Let's explore some common risks that retirees face:

Investment Risk: This refers to the risk of choosing the wrong investments, such as allocating all your money to a single stock or a narrow sector. Concentrating your portfolio in a few investments exposes you to significant risk if those particular holdings perform poorly.

Diversification is key to mitigating investment risk and ensuring that your retirement savings are spread across a range of assets.

Timing Risk: Attempting to time the market by constantly shifting in and out of investments based on short-term factors like economic news, political events, or market fluctuations is a significant risk. Trying to outsmart the market by predicting its movements often leads to poor investment decisions and can result in missing out on potential gains. A disciplined, long-term approach is generally more effective than reactive, short-term trading.

Sequence of Return Risk: This risk is particularly relevant for retirees who need to withdraw money from their investment accounts to fund their living expenses. If the market experiences a significant downturn and you're forced to sell investments at a loss to generate income, you can't fully recover that money since you're no longer contributing to your portfolio through employment.

The order and timing of market returns can have a substantial impact on the longevity of your retirement savings. On the flip side, being overly conservative also comes with its own set of risks:

Inflation Risk: Keeping too much money in cash or low-yielding investments can erode the purchasing power of your savings over time due to inflation. As the cost of goods and services rises, your money may not stretch as far in the future if your investments aren't keeping pace with inflation. Maintaining a portion of your portfolio in growth-oriented assets can help combat inflation risk.

Longevity Risk: With advancements in healthcare and increasing life expectancies, many retirees face the possibility of outliving their money. If you're not growing your wealth through a balanced investment approach, you may be at risk of running out of funds, especially if you have a long retirement time horizon.

Investing too conservatively can hinder your ability to generate the returns necessary to sustain your lifestyle over an extended retirement.

Interest Rate Risk: Even bonds, which are often considered a safer investment compared to stocks, can be affected by changes in interest rates. In 2022, corporate bonds experienced a significant loss of 12-13% due to rising interest rates.

When interest rates increase, the value of existing bonds typically decreases, as new bonds are issued with higher yields. This highlights the importance of understanding the potential risks associated with fixed-income investments.


To address both the risks of being too aggressive and too conservative, it's crucial to find a balanced approach that aligns with your unique retirement income needs and goals.

Developing a personalized investment plan that takes into account your specific circumstances is key to achieving a worry-free retirement. One effective strategy is implementing a three-bucket retirement investment plan, which can help you navigate the complexities of retirement investing.

Bucket 1: Cash and Money Market Funds (1-2 Years of Living Expenses)

The first bucket of your retirement investment plan should consist of safe, conservative assets that you'll need to access within the next 1-2 years. It's recommended to have at least 1-2 years' worth of living expenses in cash or cash equivalents, such as money market funds.

This money should be easily accessible and not subject to the volatility of the stock market. Having this cash reserve provides peace of mind, knowing that your short-term living expenses are covered, regardless of market conditions.

It's important to note that this cash bucket is separate from your emergency fund or reserve fund, which is intended to cover unexpected expenses or financial emergencies. Your cash bucket specifically addresses your near-term income needs in retirement.

Bucket 2: Bonds, Treasuries, and CDs (3-4 Years of Living Expenses)

The second bucket of your retirement investment plan is designed to provide a modest return without the expectation of substantial growth. This bucket should consist of relatively safe, fixed-income assets such as bonds, treasuries, and certificates of deposit (CDs). The purpose of this bucket is to bridge the gap between your short-term cash needs and your long-term growth investments.

Having 3-4 years' worth of living expenses in this bucket is generally recommended. These investments are still fairly liquid, meaning you can access the funds if needed, but they offer the potential for slightly higher returns compared to cash.

By allocating a portion of your portfolio to fixed-income assets, you can help stabilize your overall investment mix and reduce the impact of stock market volatility on your retirement income.

Bucket 3: Stocks (Long-Term Growth)

The third bucket of your retirement investment plan is focused on long-term growth and is typically invested in stocks or stock mutual funds. This portion of your portfolio is designed to outpace inflation and provide the potential for capital appreciation over an extended time horizon. The investments in this bucket are intended to fund your retirement income needs 10, 20, or even 30 years down the line.

By allocating a portion of your retirement assets to stocks, you can participate in the long-term growth potential of the stock market. While stocks are generally more volatile than bonds or cash, they have historically provided higher returns over longer periods.

The key is to have a well-diversified portfolio that includes a mix of domestic and international stocks, as well as a balance of large-cap, mid-cap, and small-cap companies.

It's important to note that the specific allocation to each bucket will vary based on your individual circumstances, risk tolerance, and retirement income needs. Working with a financial professional can help you determine the appropriate allocation for your unique situation.

Example: John and Mary's Three-Bucket Retirement Plan

To illustrate how the three-bucket retirement investment plan works in practice, let's consider an example. John and Mary, a retired couple, have a total of $1 million in their retirement savings. They have determined that they need to withdraw $50,000 per year from their investment portfolio to support their desired lifestyle in retirement.

Based on the three-bucket approach, here's how John and Mary's retirement investment plan might be structured:

  • Bucket 1: $100,000 in cash and money market funds (covering 2 years of living expenses)
  • Bucket 2: $150,000 in bonds, treasuries, and CDs (covering 3 years of living expenses)
  • Bucket 3: $750,000 in stocks (remaining funds for long-term growth)

With this allocation, John and Mary have a five-year buffer, which allows them to confidently retire without being overly concerned about short-term stock market fluctuations. When the markets are experiencing a downturn, they can comfortably withdraw from buckets 1 and 2 to fund their living expenses, giving their stock investments in bucket 3 time to recover.

During periods when the markets are performing well, John and Mary can strategically refill buckets 1 and 2 with gains from bucket 3, ensuring that they always maintain a sufficient cash and fixed-income cushion.

This approach helps them avoid the pitfalls of being too conservative and missing out on potential growth, while also providing a sense of financial security.


Creating a three-bucket retirement investment plan tailored to your specific income needs is a powerful strategy for achieving a worry-free retirement. By segmenting your retirement assets into distinct buckets—cash for short-term needs, fixed-income for mid-term stability, and stocks for long-term growth—you can strike a balance between preserving your wealth and capitalizing on market opportunities.

The key is to avoid being overly conservative or aggressive and instead find an allocation that aligns with your unique retirement goals and risk tolerance. By understanding the true risks associated with retirement investing, developing a personalized investment plan, and implementing a three-bucket strategy, you can navigate the complexities of retirement with greater confidence and peace of mind.

Remember, retirement planning is not a one-size-fits-all endeavor. It's essential to regularly review and adjust your investment plan as your circumstances and goals evolve over time.

Working with a trusted financial professional can provide valuable guidance and support in crafting and maintaining a retirement investment strategy that helps you achieve the worry-free retirement you deserve.

 👉 If you would like to get a FREE retirement assessment, click the link to schedule your 20-minute call to start the retirement assessment process.

// new code add in home