RMDs Meet Market Crashes in the Perfect Storm That Could Ruin Your Retirement

When John, one of my long-term clients, reached out with a question about required minimum distributions (RMDs) and sequence of returns risk, I knew he was touching on one of the most overlooked yet critical aspects of retirement planning. His concern was simple but profound: "What happens if I'm forced to withdraw money from my retirement accounts during a market crash?"

This scenario keeps many pre-retirees awake at night, and for good reason. The intersection of RMDs and sequence of returns risk can create what I call the "perfect storm" that could potentially devastate even the most well-funded retirement plans.

But here's the good news: with proper planning and the right strategies, you can weather this storm and even turn it into a gentle breeze.

I'll walk you through everything you need to know about RMDs and sequence of returns risk, and more importantly, I'll show you exactly how to protect your retirement from this dangerous combination. Whether you're years away from RMDs or already taking them, this guide will help you navigate these waters with confidence.

What Are Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs)?

Let's start with the basics. Required minimum distributions are exactly what they sound like—the minimum amount the IRS requires you to withdraw from certain tax-deferred retirement accounts each year once you reach a specific age. Think of it as the government's way of saying, "We've waited long enough for our tax revenue; it's time to pay up."

RMD Basics and Current Rules

The current RMD rules are more complex than they used to be, thanks to recent legislation. Here's what you need to know:

Age Requirements:

If you were born between 1951 and 1959, your RMDs begin at age 73
If you were born in 1960 or later, your RMDs begin at age 75
This represents a significant shift from the previous age 70½ requirement

Affected Account Types:

Traditional IRAs
401(k) plans
403(b) plans
457(b) plans
SEP-IRAs
SIMPLE IRAs

Note: Roth IRAs are exempt from RMD requirements during the owner's lifetime—one of their most powerful benefits.

Calculation Method: Your RMD is calculated by dividing your account balance as of December 31 of the previous year by your life expectancy factor from the IRS Uniform Lifetime Table. For example, if you're 75 years old with a $500,000 IRA balance, your RMD would be approximately $21,740 ($500,000 ÷ 22.9).

2025 RMD Updates and Changes

The retirement landscape continues to evolve, and 2025 brings several important considerations:

SECURE Act 2.0 Impacts:

Penalty reductions for missed RMDs (down from 50% to 10% in some cases)
Increased catch-up contribution limits for those approaching retirement
Enhanced flexibility in employer-sponsored plans

Legislative Watch: Keep an eye on potential future changes to RMD ages and calculation methods. The trend has been toward delaying RMDs, which generally benefits retirees by allowing more tax-deferred growth.

Common RMD Mistakes to Avoid

I've seen countless clients make costly mistakes with their RMDs. Here are the most common ones:

Missing the deadline (December 31st each year, except for your first RMD)
Calculating incorrectly when you have multiple accounts
Taking RMDs from the wrong account type
Forgetting about inherited IRAs (which have different rules)
Not coordinating with overall tax planning

Understanding Sequence of Returns Risk in Retirement

Now, let's dive into the concept that many financial professionals consider the "silent killer" of retirement plans: sequence of returns risk.

What Is Sequence of Returns Risk?

Sequence of returns risk is the danger that poor investment returns early in your retirement can permanently damage your ability to maintain your desired lifestyle throughout retirement. It's not just about the average return over time—it's about when those returns occur.

Here's a simple way to think about it: imagine two retirees, Sarah and Michael, both retiring with $1 million and identical investment returns over 20 years. The only difference is that Sarah experiences her worst returns in years 1-5, while Michael experiences his worst returns in years 16-20. Despite having the same average returns, Sarah's portfolio will be decimated while Michael's will thrive.

Why This Happens: When you're withdrawing money from a declining portfolio, you're forced to sell more shares to meet your income needs. This leaves fewer shares to participate in any future market recovery. It's like trying to refill a bucket with a hole in the bottom—the hole gets bigger as the water level drops.

Real-World Examples and Case Studies

Let me share a powerful example from recent market history. Consider two investors who retired in 2007 versus 2009:

The 2007 Retiree:

Retired with $1 million
Immediately faced the 2008 financial crisis
Had to sell stocks at depressed prices to meet living expenses
Portfolio value dropped to approximately $600,000
Never fully recovered despite the subsequent bull market

The 2009 Retiree:

Retired with $1 million after markets had already crashed
Benefited from the longest bull market in history
Portfolio grew substantially over the following decade
Maintained their desired lifestyle comfortably

This real-world example illustrates why sequence of returns risk is so crucial to understand and plan for.

Early vs. Late Retirement Sequence Risk

The timing of poor returns makes all the difference:

Early Retirement (Years 1-10):

Highest risk period
Portfolio has less time to recover
Withdrawals compound the damage
Can permanently impair retirement security

Late Retirement (Years 15+):

Lower risk period
Smaller portfolio base means less absolute loss
Fewer years remaining for withdrawals
Less time needed for recovery

The key insight: The first decade of retirement is absolutely critical for your long-term financial security.

The Dangerous Intersection: How RMDs Amplify Sequence Risk

Here's where things get particularly concerning. RMDs can significantly amplify sequence of returns risk by forcing you to withdraw money at the worst possible times.

The Perfect Storm Scenario

Picture this scenario, which is exactly what Paul was worried about:

Market Crash: Your portfolio drops 30% in February
RMD Calculation: Your RMD is still calculated based on the previous year's higher balance
Forced Withdrawal: You must withdraw 4-6% of what your portfolio was worth, not what it's worth now
Compounding Damage: You're selling at the bottom to meet your RMD requirements

This creates a vicious cycle where you're forced to realize losses, leaving less money to participate in any market recovery.

Quantifying the Risk

Let me show you the numbers. Using a hypothetical $1 million portfolio:

Scenario	Portfolio Value	RMD Required	Effective Withdrawal Rate
Normal Year	$1,000,000	$43,478 (4.35%)	4.35%
30% Down Year	$700,000	$43,478 (still)	6.21%
50% Down Year	$500,000	$43,478 (still)	8.70%

As you can see, the effective withdrawal rate skyrockets during down markets, potentially pushing you into dangerous territory where recovery becomes nearly impossible.

Who Is Most at Risk?

Certain retirees face higher exposure to RMD sequence risk:

High-Risk Profiles:

Large traditional IRA/401(k) balances (over $500,000)
Heavy concentration in tax-deferred accounts
Limited taxable investment accounts
Early retirees (62-67) approaching RMD age
Those with aggressive asset allocations

Lower-Risk Profiles:

Balanced mix of account types (traditional, Roth, taxable)
Conservative asset allocations
Substantial cash reserves
Flexible spending patterns
Later retirees with shorter RMD periods

Advanced Strategies to Mitigate RMD Sequence Risk

Now for the good news: there are numerous strategies you can implement to protect yourself from this perfect storm. Let's explore the most effective approaches.

Roth Conversion Strategies

Roth conversions are one of the most powerful tools in your arsenal for reducing RMD sequence risk. Here's why they're so effective:

The Magic of Roth Conversions:

Every dollar converted is one less dollar subject to RMDs
Conversions can be timed strategically during market downturns
You pay taxes now to avoid forced withdrawals later
Creates tax-free growth for your heirs

Optimal Timing for Conversions:

Market Downturns: Convert when your account values are depressed
Low-Income Years: Between retirement and Social Security/RMD age
Tax Planning Windows: Fill up current tax brackets before rates potentially increase

Laddering Techniques: Instead of massive one-time conversions, consider a systematic approach:

Convert a specific dollar amount annually
Target staying within your current tax bracket
Spread conversions over multiple years to manage tax impact

Pro tip: Consider converting enough to keep your future RMDs at manageable levels, even if it means paying some taxes now.

Strategic Withdrawal Timing

The timing of your RMD withdrawals can significantly impact sequence risk:

Dollar-Cost Averaging Out: Rather than taking your entire RMD in one lump sum, consider spreading it throughout the year:

Monthly withdrawals reduce timing risk
Quarterly withdrawals balance convenience with risk reduction
Avoid the temptation to "time the market"

Market Consideration Strategies:

Early January: Take RMDs immediately to avoid market volatility
Market Volatility: Increase withdrawal frequency during volatile periods
Bull Markets: Consider taking next year's RMD early if beneficial

Asset Location and Rebalancing

Smart asset location can help minimize RMD sequence risk:

Tax-Efficient Positioning:

Hold growth assets in Roth accounts
Keep income-producing assets in traditional accounts
Maintain liquidity in taxable accounts

Rebalancing Strategies:

Use RMDs as rebalancing opportunities
Sell overweight positions to meet RMD requirements
Maintain target allocations across all account types

Tax Optimization Strategies for RMDs

RMDs don't just create sequence risk—they can also trigger significant tax consequences. Here's how to minimize the damage:

Managing IRMAA Surcharges

IRMAA (Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount) can significantly increase your Medicare premiums. Here's how RMDs can push you into higher IRMAA brackets:

2025 IRMAA Thresholds (Individual/Married Filing Jointly):

$103,000 / $206,000: Standard premium
$129,000 / $258,000: +$69.90/month
$161,000 / $322,000: +$174.70/month
$193,000 / $386,000: +$279.60/month

Planning Strategies:

Monitor your income carefully as you approach thresholds
Consider Roth conversions in years when you're already over the threshold
Use qualified charitable distributions to reduce IRMAA exposure

RMDs can also increase the taxation of your Social Security benefits by pushing you over provisional income thresholds:

Provisional Income Thresholds:

Individual: $25,000-$34,000 (50% taxable) / $34,000+ (85% taxable)
Married Filing Jointly: $32,000-$44,000 (50% taxable) / $44,000+ (85% taxable)

Optimization Techniques:

Coordinate RMD timing with Social Security claiming strategies
Consider delaying Social Security if RMDs push you over thresholds
Use tax-free income sources when possible

Qualified Charitable Distributions (QCDs)

If you're charitably inclined, QCDs can be incredibly powerful:

QCD Benefits:

Counts toward your RMD requirement
Excluded from taxable income
Available starting at age 70½
Up to $105,000 annually (2025 limit)

Strategic Implementation:

Direct transfer from IRA to qualified charity
Reduces adjusted gross income
Helps avoid IRMAA and Social Security taxation thresholds

Portfolio Construction for RMD-Era Retirees

Your portfolio structure becomes even more critical when RMDs enter the picture. Here's how to build a portfolio that can weather the storm:

Asset Allocation Adjustments

The traditional advice of "your age in bonds" may not be appropriate for RMD-era retirees facing sequence risk:

Modern Asset Allocation Considerations:

Equity Allocation: Consider maintaining 50-70% in stocks even after age 70
Bond Allocation: 20-30% in high-quality bonds and bond alternatives
Alternative Investments: 10-20% in REITs, commodities, or other diversifiers

Risk Tolerance Factors:

Higher Risk Tolerance: More aggressive allocations may be appropriate with longer lifespans
Flexibility: Ability to reduce spending during down markets
Other Income Sources: Pensions, Social Security, rental income

Income-Focused Strategies

Building a portfolio that generates natural income can help reduce the need to sell assets during downturns:

Dividend-Focused Approaches:

High-quality dividend-paying stocks
Dividend growth stocks with increasing payments
Dividend-focused mutual funds or ETFs

Bond Strategies:

Bond Ladders: Systematic maturity dates provide predictable income
Duration Matching: Match bond maturities with expected expenses
Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS): Protect against inflation

Liquidity Management

Maintaining adequate liquidity is crucial for RMD-era retirees:

Cash Buffer Strategies:

Emergency Fund: 6-12 months of expenses in high-yield savings
RMD Fund: Set aside 1-2 years of RMDs in stable investments
Opportunity Fund: Cash available for market downturns or Roth conversions

Short-Term Reserves:

Money market funds
Short-term CDs
High-yield savings accounts
Short-term government bonds

Case Studies: Real-World RMD Sequence Risk Scenarios

Let me share three hypothetical scenarios that illustrate different approaches to managing RMD sequence risk:

Case Study 1: The 2008 Retiree

Background: Meet Janet, who retired in December 2007 with a $1.2 million traditional IRA, planning to live on $60,000 annually (5% withdrawal rate).

The Challenge:

2008 market crash reduced her portfolio to $720,000
RMDs began in 2018, calculated on pre-crash values
Portfolio never fully recovered due to ongoing withdrawals

The Outcome:

Portfolio depleted to under $400,000 by 2020
Forced to reduce lifestyle significantly
Became dependent on Social Security as primary income source

Lessons Learned:

Sequence risk is real and devastating
High withdrawal rates compound the problem
Lack of flexibility can be catastrophic

Case Study 2: The Well-Prepared Retiree

Background: Robert retired in 2010 with a more conservative approach:

$800,000 in traditional IRAs
$300,000 in Roth IRAs
$200,000 in taxable accounts
Target withdrawal rate of 3.5%

The Strategy:

Systematic Roth conversions from 2010-2019
Used taxable accounts for living expenses during market downturns
Maintained 18-month cash buffer
Flexible spending plan

The Outcome:

Successfully navigated multiple market downturns
RMDs began at manageable levels due to Roth conversions
Portfolio grew despite regular withdrawals
Maintained desired lifestyle throughout retirement

Key Success Factors:

Diversified account types
Proactive planning
Flexibility in spending
Long-term perspective

Case Study 3: The Corrective Action

Background: Susan found herself in trouble in 2018:

$900,000 traditional IRA
Just started RMDs
Market volatility creating stress

The Correction:

Implemented immediate Roth conversion strategy
Converted $100,000 annually for three years
Used QCDs for charitable giving
Adjusted asset allocation to be more conservative

The Result:

Reduced future RMD requirements by 35%
Improved tax efficiency
Better positioned for market volatility
Regained confidence in retirement plan

Key Insights:

It's never too late to implement corrective strategies
Small changes can have significant long-term impacts
Professional guidance can help navigate complex situations

Action Steps: Your RMD Sequence Risk Checklist

Now that you understand the risks and strategies, here's your action plan:

Immediate Actions (Next 30 Days)

Assessment Phase:

[ ] Calculate your projected RMDs using current account balances
[ ] Determine your effective withdrawal rate during various market scenarios
[ ] Review your current asset allocation across all account types
[ ] Assess your cash reserves and liquidity needs

Quick Wins:

[ ] Set up automatic monthly or quarterly RMD withdrawals
[ ] Research qualified charitable distribution opportunities
[ ] Consider immediate Roth conversion opportunities
[ ] Review your estate planning documents

Short-term Planning (Next 6-12 Months)

Strategic Implementation:

[ ] Develop a systematic Roth conversion strategy
[ ] Rebalance your portfolio with RMD considerations in mind
[ ] Create a tax-efficient withdrawal sequence
[ ] Build or increase your cash buffer

Professional Coordination:

[ ] Meet with your financial advisor to review RMD strategies
[ ] Consult with your tax professional about conversion opportunities
[ ] Consider working with a fee-only financial planner for objective advice

Long-term Strategy (1-5 Years)

Comprehensive Planning:

[ ] Implement a multi-year Roth conversion ladder
[ ] Optimize your asset location across account types
[ ] Develop flexible spending strategies
[ ] Create contingency plans for market downturns

Advanced Strategies:

[ ] Consider insurance strategies for guaranteed income
[ ] Explore annuity options for income floor protection
[ ] Investigate tax-efficient investment vehicles
[ ] Plan for potential healthcare costs and long-term care needs

Annual Review Process

Yearly Checkpoints:

[ ] Review and adjust RMD projections
[ ] Assess Roth conversion opportunities
[ ] Rebalance portfolio based on RMD requirements
[ ] Update tax planning strategies

Market Response:

[ ] Adjust withdrawal timing based on market conditions
[ ] Consider additional Roth conversions during downturns
[ ] Rebalance to maintain target allocations
[ ] Review and update contingency plans

Key Takeaways

Critical Concepts

Sequence of returns risk is real and potentially devastating, especially when combined with forced RMD withdrawals during market downturns.
The first decade of retirement is the most critical period for your long-term financial security—this is when sequence risk has the greatest impact.
RMDs can amplify sequence risk by forcing you to sell investments at the worst possible times, creating a vicious cycle of portfolio depletion.
Proactive planning is essential—waiting until RMDs begin significantly limits your options and flexibility.

Most Effective Strategies

Roth conversions are your best defense against RMD sequence risk, allowing you to reduce future required distributions while potentially benefiting from tax-free growth.
Diversification across account types (traditional, Roth, and taxable) provides maximum flexibility in managing taxes and withdrawals.
Strategic withdrawal timing through dollar-cost averaging and market-aware approaches can significantly reduce sequence risk.
Maintaining adequate liquidity allows you to avoid selling investments during market downturns.

Planning Priorities

Start planning now, regardless of your age—the earlier you begin, the more options you have available.
Work with qualified professionals who understand the complexity of RMD and sequence risk planning.
Remain flexible in your approach, as tax laws, market conditions, and personal circumstances will change over time.
Regular review and adjustment of your strategies ensures they remain aligned with your goals and market conditions.

Final Thoughts

Remember, Paul's concern about RMDs and sequence risk was valid—but it's not insurmountable. With proper planning, strategic implementation, and professional guidance, you can protect your retirement from this perfect storm. The key is to start planning now, remain flexible, and focus on strategies that give you the most control over your financial destiny.

The intersection of RMDs and sequence of returns risk represents one of the most significant challenges in retirement planning, but it's also one of the most manageable with proper preparation. Don't let this silent threat derail your retirement dreams—take action today to protect your financial future.

For more detailed information about RMD requirements and calculations, visit the IRS official guidance on Required Minimum Distributions. If you're interested in learning more about sequence of returns risk and its impact on retirement planning, Morningstar's research on sequence risk provides excellent insights from industry experts.

👉 If you would like to get a FREE retirement assessment, click the link to schedule your 20-minute call to start the retirement assessment process.