Pre-Tax vs. Roth: Which Retirement Account is Better in Peak Earning Years?

Retirement planning can be confusing, with many important choices that impact your finances in later years. One of the key choices is whether to put money into a Roth account or a traditional pre-tax retirement account. For retirees, understanding this decision is important for good tax planning and keeping their finances stable.

This article explains why, even if future tax rates go up, putting money into pre-tax retirement accounts during your highest-earning years might still be the best choice.

It looks at how income levels change throughout life, why timing matters when it comes to paying taxes, and how retirees can make the most of their withdrawals to lower taxes.

By the end, readers will have a clear understanding of how to approach pre-tax vs. Roth contributions as part of their retirement plan.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

• Peak Earning Years Are Ideal for Pre-Tax Contributions: During high-income years, pre-tax contributions can help reduce taxable income, providing immediate tax benefits.
• Tax Rates Often Drop in Retirement: Many retirees find themselves in lower tax brackets after they stop working, making it advantageous to defer taxes until those years.
• Strategic Roth Conversions Can Minimize Taxes: Converting pre-tax funds to Roth during low-income years allows retirees to lock in lower tax rates and reduce future RMDs.
• Tax Diversification Provides Flexibility: Having a mix of pre-tax and Roth accounts allows retirees to adapt to changing tax laws and manage their income to minimize taxes.
• Managing Income Levels Is Key: Careful planning around Social Security, RMDs, and Roth conversions can help retirees stay in lower tax brackets and reduce their overall tax burden.
• Consider Medicare Premiums and State Taxes: Strategic income management can help retirees avoid higher Medicare premiums and minimize state taxes, further optimizing their financial situation.
• Qualified Charitable Distributions Can Reduce Taxable Income: Using QCDs to satisfy RMDs can help retirees fulfill charitable goals while reducing their taxable income.

UNDERSTANDING PRE-TAX VS. ROTH CONTRIBUTIONS

When saving for retirement, there are two main types of tax-advantaged accounts: traditional pre-tax accounts and Roth accounts. Each of these accounts has different rules about when you pay taxes, both when you put money in and when you take it out

• Traditional Pre-Tax Accounts: Contributions to these accounts are made before taxes are taken out, which means you get a tax deduction when you put the money in. The investments grow without being taxed until you take them out, and then they are taxed as regular income. Examples include traditional 401(k)s and IRAs.
• Roth Accounts: Contributions to Roth accounts are made with money that has already been taxed, so there is no tax deduction when you contribute. However, when you take the money out in retirement, it is completely tax-free, including any growth from the investments. Examples include Roth IRAs and Roth 401(k)s.

The choice between these two comes down to one key factor: tax rates. Specifically, it depends on comparing your current tax rate when you put the money in to your expected tax rate when you plan to take the money out in retirement.

THE ROTH VS. TRADITIONAL DEBATE: A TAX RATE PERSPECTIVE

The debate over Roth vs. traditional contributions is really about tax rates. If you expect your tax rate to be higher in retirement, it makes sense to contribute to a Roth account.

But if you think your tax rate will be lower in retirement, then contributing to a traditional pre-tax account could be a better choice.

For retirees in their peak earning years, the key question is whether they will benefit from making pre-tax contributions now and paying the taxes later at a lower rate in retirement.

Often, retirees see a big drop in income when they stop working, allowing them to take money out of pre-tax accounts at lower tax rates compared to when they were working.

Example Scenario

Imagine someone earning $150,000 per year during their highest-earning years, which puts them in a high tax bracket. If they contribute $10,000 to a traditional pre-tax account, they won't have to pay taxes on that $10,000 at their current rate, which could save them a lot of money.

When they retire and their income drops, they might be able to take out that $10,000 at a much lower tax rate. By deferring taxes until retirement, they can reduce their overall tax burden, assuming their retirement tax rate will be lower.

WHY HISTORICAL TAX RATES ARE MISLEADING

Some financial experts say that pre-tax accounts are a "tax time bomb" because future tax rates will likely go up. This idea comes from looking at U.S. tax history, where rates were as high as 90% in the 1950s and 1960s. However, these comparisons can be misleading for a few reasons.

• High Tax Rates Affected Few People: In the mid-1900s, the highest tax brackets only applied to people earning the equivalent of millions of dollars today, so very few people actually paid those high rates.
• Expanding the Tax Base: Modern tax changes have focused on broadening the base of income that gets taxed instead of just raising tax rates. This means fewer deductions and credits, making more income subject to tax, even if the rates are lower.

This means that while top tax rates could rise again, they are not likely to affect most retirees in a big way. It's more likely that we will see changes to deductions and credits rather than a return to extremely high tax rates.

INDIVIDUAL TAX RATE CHANGES VS. NATIONAL TAX POLICY

While national tax rates can change, individual tax rates also change a lot because of life events. For retirees, income levels usually follow a pattern:

• Peak Earning Years: During these years, income is highest, leading to higher tax rates.
• Early Retirement: When people first retire, their income often drops sharply, putting them in lower tax brackets. This is a good time to withdraw from pre-tax accounts or convert funds to a Roth.
• Later Retirement: When retirees start taking Social Security and Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs), their income can go up again, but it usually doesn't reach the same level as during their peak working years.

Understanding these phases is key to making smart decisions about when to put money into or take money out of retirement accounts.

STRATEGIC ROTH CONVERSIONS: TIMING MATTERS

One of the biggest advantages of contributing to a pre-tax account is the flexibility it gives you during retirement. Retirees can decide when to convert pre-tax funds to a Roth account, and this can be very helpful during the years right after retirement but before taking Social Security or RMDs.

• Low-Income Years: During these years, retirees may be in the lowest tax brackets of their lives. By converting pre-tax funds to Roth during this time, they can "lock in" a low tax rate and reduce their future tax burden.
• Roth Conversion Benefits: Converting funds to Roth during low-income years also helps reduce the size of pre-tax accounts, which means smaller RMDs and lower taxes in the future.

For example, if a retiree has $500,000 in a traditional IRA, they could convert part of it to a Roth IRA each year, up to the top of their current tax bracket, to avoid going into a higher tax rate.

MANAGING RETIREMENT INCOME LEVELS

The goal of strategic retirement planning is to minimize taxes by managing income levels throughout retirement. Here are some practical strategies:

• Delay Social Security: Delaying Social Security benefits until age 70 can maximize monthly payments and keep taxable income lower in earlier years.
• Roth Conversions: Use low-income years to convert pre-tax funds to Roth, reducing the size of pre-tax accounts and minimizing RMDs later.
• Tax Bracket Management: Plan withdrawals carefully to stay in lower tax brackets, especially before RMDs start.

These strategies can help retirees make the most of their retirement savings by optimizing their tax situation.

FILLING TAX BRACKETS TO "LOCK IN" LOW RATES

A key strategy for maximizing retirement savings is to use up lower tax brackets with Roth conversions. This means converting just enough pre-tax funds each year to fill the lower brackets without moving into a higher one.

For instance, if a retiree is in the 12% tax bracket, they could convert pre-tax funds up to the top of that bracket, making sure they pay the lowest rate possible on those funds. By doing this year after year, they can reduce the size of their pre-tax accounts and avoid higher tax rates in the future.

THE FLEXIBILITY ADVANTAGE OF PRE-TAX ACCOUNTS

One of the benefits of pre-tax accounts that is often overlooked is their flexibility. Unlike Roth accounts, which don’t allow you to reverse contributions or take deductions in high-income years, pre-tax accounts let you decide when to recognize income.

This flexibility is really valuable in uncertain tax environments. Retirees can decide when to convert pre-tax funds to Roth, making it easier to adjust to changing tax laws and income situations. This adaptability makes pre-tax accounts an important part of a good retirement strategy.

THE "TAX TIME BOMB" MYTH

The idea that traditional pre-tax accounts are a "tax time bomb" assumes that future tax rates will be much higher. But this view overlooks some important things:

• Tax Diversification: Having a mix of pre-tax and Roth accounts allows retirees to adjust their withdrawal strategy to minimize taxes, no matter what future tax rates are.
• Income Management: Retirees can manage their income to stay in lower tax brackets, especially in the years before RMDs start
• Policy Uncertainty: Tax laws are uncertain. While tax rates might go up, it’s just as likely that future changes will reduce deductions or credits instead of increasing rates.

By understanding these details, retirees can make smarter decisions about their contributions and withdrawals, avoiding oversimplified tax predictions.

COMMON MISCONCEPTIONS ABOUT ROTH CONVERSIONS

There are a few common misunderstandings about Roth contributions that are worth discussing:

• "Roth is Always Better If Tax Rates Go Up": While Roth contributions are better if tax rates go up, this only helps if your personal tax rate in retirement is higher than it was when you were working. For many retirees, their income—and tax rate—drops significantly in retirement, making pre-tax contributions more beneficial.
• "Roth Accounts Are Risk-Free From Tax Changes": Some people think Roth accounts are completely protected from future tax law changes. But Congress could change the rules, like adding RMDs or putting limits on how much can be held tax-free in a Roth.
• "Everyone Should Avoid Pre-Tax Accounts": This advice ignores that tax planning is personal. For people in high tax brackets today, contributing to a pre-tax account and managing withdrawals later can be much better than paying taxes upfront on Roth contributions.

ADDITONAL CONSIDERATIONS FOR RETIREES

Retirement planning isn't just about saving as much as possible—it's also about understanding how different types of income interact and affect overall taxes. Here are some additional things to consider:

• Qualified Charitable Distributions (QCDs): Retirees who like to donate to charity can use QCDs to give directly from their pre-tax retirement accounts, satisfying RMD requirements without increasing their taxable income.
• Medicare Premiums: Managing taxable income is important because higher income can lead to increased Medicare premiums. Using a mix of withdrawals from pre-tax and Roth accounts can help keep income below thresholds that lead to higher costs.
• Estate Planning: Roth accounts can be helpful in estate planning. Unlike traditional pre-tax accounts, Roth IRAs are not subject to RMDs during the original owner's life, allowing them to grow tax-free longer. This can be a big benefit to heirs, especially if they are in higher tax brackets.
• State Taxes: State income tax rules also matter. Some states don’t tax Social Security or have lower rates for retirement income. Understanding these rules can help retirees decide if pre-tax or Roth contributions are better.

PRACTICAL EXAMPLES OF TAX MANAGEMENT

To better understand these strategies, let’s look at a couple of examples:

Scenario 1: The Early Retiree

John is 62 years old and recently retired with $1 million in a traditional IRA. He plans to delay Social Security benefits until age 70 to maximize his benefit. Over the next eight years, John can convert $50,000 per year from his traditional IRA to a Roth IRA, staying within the 12% tax bracket. By the time he reaches age 70, he will have converted $400,000 to a Roth, reducing his future RMDs and locking in a low tax rate on those funds.

Scenario 2: Managing RMDs

Sarah is 75 years old and must take RMDs from her $800,000 traditional IRA. She also has a Roth IRA and taxable investment accounts. To minimize her tax burden, Sarah takes her RMD but avoids selling assets from her taxable account, which would trigger capital gains taxes. Instead, she draws from her Roth IRA to cover additional expenses, keeping her taxable income as low as possible.

These examples show how strategic planning can help retirees manage their income, reduce taxes, and make the most of their retirement savings.

CONCLUSION

Deciding between Roth and traditional pre-tax contributions is not a one-size-fits-all decision. For many retirees, especially those in their peak earning years, contributing to a traditional pre-tax account can offer significant tax advantages.

By strategically managing withdrawals and considering Roth conversions during low-income years, retirees can minimize their tax burden and maximize their retirement savings.

Understanding how tax rates change both nationally and personally is key to making informed decisions. With a well-thought-out plan, retirees can effectively manage their income, optimize their tax situation, and enjoy a more financially secure retirement.

Retirement planning is about more than just saving—it's about using the right strategies to ensure that those savings go as far as possible. With the right mix of pre-tax contributions, Roth conversions, and income management, retirees can navigate the complexities of tax planning and create a retirement that is both comfortable and financially efficient.

👉 If you would like to get a FREE retirement assessment, click the link to schedule your 20-minute call to start the retirement assessment process.