Per Stirpes vs Per Capita: The $500,000 Beneficiary Mistake That Could Cost Your Family

Sarah thought she had everything figured out. Her retirement accounts were worth over $800,000, and she had carefully named her two adult children as equal beneficiaries on all her accounts. What she didn't realize was that a single checkbox marked "per capita" instead of "per stirpes" would completely change her family's financial future.

When Sarah's daughter Emily passed away unexpectedly, leaving behind two young children, Sarah discovered a shocking truth. Because she hadn't selected per stirpes beneficiary designations, Emily's $400,000 share wouldn't go to her grandchildren—it would all go to her surviving son instead. Those two grandchildren, the ones Emily had worked so hard to provide for, would receive nothing from their grandmother's retirement savings.

Per stirpes is a legal term that ensures if one of your beneficiaries dies before you do, their share of your inheritance automatically passes to their children or descendants. This simple estate planning decision can mean the difference between your assets staying within each family branch or being redistributed in ways you never intended.

More than half of American adults don't have proper estate planning documents, and even fewer understand how beneficiary designations work on their retirement accounts. Yet these designations control how millions of dollars in retirement savings get distributed every year.

Key Takeaways

• Per stirpes ensures your assets stay within each family branch by passing a deceased beneficiary's share to their children, while per capita redistributes assets among surviving beneficiaries

• Review and update your beneficiary designations annually and after major life events like births, deaths, marriages, or divorces to ensure your wishes are properly documented

• Not all retirement accounts offer per stirpes options—employer 401(k) plans may have limitations that require rolling over to an IRA for more flexibility

• Per stirpes only includes direct descendants (children, grandchildren, great-grandchildren) and doesn't cover stepchildren, spouses of beneficiaries, or other relatives unless specifically named

• Coordinate your beneficiary designations with your overall estate plan since these designations supersede your will and control how your largest assets are distributed

• Consider the ages and circumstances of potential beneficiaries when choosing between per stirpes and per capita, especially if minor grandchildren might inherit substantial amounts

What Per Stirpes Really Means for Your Family

The Latin Foundation That Protects Generations

The term "per stirpes" comes from Latin, meaning "by branch" or "by roots." Think of your family like a tree—each child represents a major branch, and their children (your grandchildren) are the smaller branches growing from that main limb.

When you choose per stirpes for your beneficiary designations, you're essentially saying: "I want each family branch to receive their intended share, even if the main branch (your child) isn't there anymore."

This concept has been part of estate planning for centuries, but it's become increasingly important as families have become more complex and retirement accounts have grown larger.

How Per Stirpes Works in Real Life

Let's walk through exactly how per stirpes protects your family's inheritance using a clear example.

Meet the Johnson Family:

• Robert Johnson has a $600,000 IRA
• He has three children: Michael, Lisa, and David
• Each child is named as a 33.33% beneficiary
• Michael has two children (Robert's grandchildren)
• Lisa has three children
• David has no children

Scenario 1: Everyone Survives If Robert dies and all three children are still alive, each receives $200,000. The number of grandchildren doesn't matter—per stirpes and per capita work exactly the same when all primary beneficiaries survive.

Scenario 2: Michael Dies First (With Per Stirpes) If Michael dies before Robert, here's what happens:

• Lisa receives her full share: $200,000
• David receives his full share: $200,000
• Michael's $200,000 share gets divided equally between his two children
• Each of Michael's children receives $100,000

Scenario 3: Michael Dies First (Without Per Stirpes) Without per stirpes, Michael's share would be redistributed:

• Lisa receives $300,000 (her share plus half of Michael's)
• David receives $300,000 (his share plus half of Michael's)
• Michael's children receive nothing

The difference is stark: with per stirpes, Michael's children inherit $100,000 each. Without it, they get nothing.

Per Stirpes vs. Per Capita: Understanding the Critical Difference

Per Capita: The "Equal Heads" Approach

Per capita, meaning "by head" in Latin, takes a completely different approach. Instead of keeping assets within family branches, it redistributes everything equally among surviving beneficiaries at the same generational level.

Let's use the same Johnson family example to show the difference:

Per Capita Distribution When Michael Dies First:

• The total inheritance is still $600,000
• Instead of Michael's branch getting his share, it gets redistributed
• Lisa and David each receive $300,000 (splitting the total between surviving children)
• Michael's two children receive nothing

Side-by-Side Comparison: Real Dollar Impact

Here's a table showing how different scenarios play out:

The Pro Rata Method: A Third Option

Some financial institutions offer a "pro rata" distribution method. This approach distributes assets based on predetermined percentages you assign, regardless of who survives.

For example, you might specify:

• 40% to Michael's family branch
• 35% to Lisa's family branch
• 25% to David's family branch

If Michael dies first, his children would still receive the full 40% of your estate, split equally between them.

Which Distribution Method Should You Choose?

The right choice depends on your family situation and your values about fairness. Here are key factors to consider:

Choose Per Stirpes If:

• You want to keep assets within each family branch
• You have grandchildren you want to protect
• You believe each child's family line should receive equal treatment
• You want to minimize the need for frequent beneficiary updates

Choose Per Capita If:

• You prefer assets go only to your surviving children
• You don't want minor grandchildren inheriting large sums
• You're comfortable with survivors receiving larger shares
• Your children don't have children of their own

Consider Your Grandchildren's Ages

One crucial factor many people overlook is the age and maturity of potential grandchildren beneficiaries.

If your grandchildren are currently minors, inheriting a large sum through per stirpes could create complications:

• Court-appointed guardianships may be required to manage the money
• In-laws or ex-spouses might gain control over the inheritance
• Spending restrictions could limit access until age 18 or 21

In these cases, you might consider setting up a trust structure instead of relying solely on per stirpes designations.

Account Types Where Per Stirpes Matters Most

Retirement Accounts: Your Biggest Decision

Most people's largest assets are in their retirement accounts, making this the most important place to get your beneficiary designations right.

Traditional and Roth IRAs:

• Most IRA custodians offer per stirpes options
• Easy to update and modify
• Clear inheritance tax rules for beneficiaries

Employer-Sponsored Plans:

• 401(k), 403(b), and 457 plans
• Important limitation: Some employer plans don't offer per stirpes options
• You may need to roll over to an IRA for more flexibility

Specialized Retirement Accounts:

• SEP-IRAs and SIMPLE IRAs (typically offer full per stirpes options)
• Solo 401(k)s for self-employed individuals
• Defined benefit pension plans (limited beneficiary options)

Other Financial Accounts

Life Insurance Policies: Life insurance proceeds can be substantial, making per stirpes elections crucial. Unlike retirement accounts, life insurance benefits are generally tax-free to beneficiaries, but the distribution method still matters for family fairness.

Annuities: Both immediate and deferred annuities can include per stirpes beneficiary options, though the rules vary significantly by insurance company.

Taxable Investment Accounts: While these accounts don't require beneficiary designations (they're controlled by your will), you can set up Transfer on Death (TOD) designations that may include per stirpes language.

Health Savings Accounts (HSAs): Often overlooked, HSAs can accumulate substantial balances over time. Most HSA providers offer per stirpes beneficiary options.

529 Education Savings Plans: These accounts have unique beneficiary rules, but some states allow per stirpes-style distributions to grandchildren.

Step-by-Step Implementation Process

Step 1: Inventory Your Accounts

Create a complete list of all accounts requiring beneficiary designations:

• [ ] Traditional IRA accounts
• [ ] Roth IRA accounts
• [ ] 401(k) or other employer plans
• [ ] Life insurance policies
• [ ] Annuity contracts
• [ ] HSA accounts
• [ ] Brokerage accounts with TOD designations

Step 2: Contact Each Institution

Don't assume all your accounts have the same options. Call each custodian and ask specifically:

1. "Do you offer per stirpes beneficiary designations?"
2. "What do you call this option?" (Some use different terminology)
3. "Can you send me the current beneficiary designation form?"
4. "How do I verify my current elections?"

Step 3: Review Current Designations

Many people are surprised to discover their current elections. Common findings include:

• Outdated beneficiaries (ex-spouses, deceased relatives)
• Per capita as the default (when they wanted per stirpes)
• Missing contingent beneficiaries
• Incorrect percentages that don't add up to 100%

Step 4: Complete New Forms Carefully

When filling out beneficiary designation forms:

• Use full legal names exactly as they appear on legal documents
• Include Social Security numbers when requested
• Specify the per stirpes election clearly
• Name contingent beneficiaries as backup options
• Keep copies of all submitted forms

Step 5: Follow Up and Confirm

After submitting new forms:

• Request written confirmation of the changes
• Ask for updated beneficiary statements showing your new elections
• Review statements carefully to ensure accuracy
• Store confirmation documents with other important papers

Complex Family Situations and Special Considerations

Blended Families and Stepchildren

Modern families often include stepchildren, half-siblings, and multiple marriages. Per stirpes designations only include legally adopted children—stepchildren you raised since birth but never formally adopted won't inherit through per stirpes.

Solutions for Blended Families:

• Formally adopt stepchildren if appropriate
• Name stepchildren as direct beneficiaries with specific percentages
• Consider trust structures for more complex distributions
• Update designations after marriages, divorces, or new children

Divorced Parents with Multiple Families

If your children have been divorced and remarried, per stirpes can create unexpected complications:

Example Scenario: Your son Michael divorces and remarries, having children with both wives. If Michael dies before you, per stirpes would distribute his inheritance to all his children equally—including those from his first marriage who may have no relationship with your family.

Estranged Family Members

Per stirpes doesn't consider family relationships or personal conflicts. If one of your children is estranged from the family, their children would still inherit through per stirpes if your child predeceases you.

Consider These Alternatives:

• Name specific grandchildren individually
• Use trust structures with discretionary distributions
• Include family harmony clauses in estate planning documents

Multi-Generational Wealth Transfer

For families with substantial assets, per stirpes can create generation-skipping tax complications. Current federal law (2024) allows $13.61 million per person to pass tax-free, but generation-skipping transfers have additional restrictions.

If your estate exceeds these thresholds, consult with an estate planning attorney who specializes in high-net-worth families.

Tax Implications You Need to Know

Inherited Retirement Account Rules

The SECURE Act of 2019 dramatically changed how inherited retirement accounts work:

Spouse Beneficiaries:

• Can treat inherited accounts as their own
• Can delay required distributions until age 73
• Have the most flexible options

Non-Spouse Beneficiaries (Including Children and Grandchildren):

• Must withdraw all funds within 10 years
• No annual required minimum distributions during the 10-year period
• Can time withdrawals for optimal tax planning

Minor Children Exception:

• Can stretch distributions until reaching majority age
• Then subject to 10-year rule
• Applies to grandchildren inheriting through per stirpes

Minor Children Exception: Can stretch distributions until reaching age 21 (the federally defined age of majority for inherited IRAs, regardless of state law). Then subject to 10-year rule

Integration with Your Overall Estate Plan

Coordination with Wills and Trusts

Your beneficiary designations supersede instructions in your will. This means:

• Retirement accounts pass directly to named beneficiaries
• Life insurance pays according to beneficiary forms
• Your will only controls assets without beneficiary designations

Make sure your estate planning documents work together harmoniously.

Trust as Beneficiary Considerations

Sometimes naming a trust as your beneficiary provides more control than per stirpes:

Advantages of Trust Beneficiaries:

• Control over timing of distributions
• Protection from beneficiaries' creditors
• Ability to skip irresponsible heirs
• Tax planning opportunities

Disadvantages:

• More complex and expensive to maintain
• Less flexibility for beneficiaries
• Potential loss of stretch IRA benefits

Charitable Giving Integration

If you want to include charitable giving in your estate plan, coordinate carefully with per stirpes elections:

• Split-interest gifts (part to family, part to charity)
• Charitable remainder trusts providing income to family first
• Donor-advised funds allowing family involvement in giving

Common Mistakes That Cost Families Thousands

Documentation Errors

Incorrect Legal Names: Using nicknames or informal names can delay distributions and create legal complications. Always use names exactly as they appear on Social Security cards or birth certificates.

Outdated Information:

• Former addresses that delay notifications
• Old phone numbers preventing contact
• Deceased individuals still listed as beneficiaries

Mathematical Errors: Percentages that don't add up to 100% can create distribution problems and legal disputes.

Life Event Oversights

Many people forget to update beneficiary designations after major life changes:

Birth of Grandchildren: Your per stirpes elections automatically include new grandchildren, but you should verify your elections still reflect your wishes.

Death of Beneficiaries: If one of your children dies, review all your beneficiary designations to ensure they still make sense.

Divorce and Remarriage:

• Remove ex-spouses from beneficiary designations
• Consider how new marriages affect your children's inheritances
• Update contingent beneficiaries accordingly

Institution-Specific Issues

Employer Plan Limitations: Some 401(k) plans don't offer per stirpes options. If this flexibility is important to you, consider rolling over to an IRA upon retirement or job change.

Rollover Timing: When moving money between retirement accounts, temporary gaps in beneficiary coverage can occur. Complete new beneficiary forms immediately after rollovers.

Multi-Custodian Coordination: Having accounts at multiple institutions increases the chance of inconsistent beneficiary elections. Maintain a master list and review it annually.

State-by-State Legal Variations

Community Property States

Nine states follow community property laws that can affect beneficiary designations:

Community Property States: Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Washington, Wisconsin

Key Implications:

• Spouses may have rights to retirement account benefits regardless of beneficiary designations
• Per stirpes elections may be limited without spousal consent
• Consult local attorneys for state-specific rules

Forced Heirship Considerations

Louisiana has unique "forced heirship" laws that can override beneficiary designations in certain circumstances, particularly when minor children are involved.

Multi-State Planning Issues

If you own property or have family members in multiple states, coordinate your planning carefully:

• Domicile rules determine which state laws apply
• Account location vs. residence can create conflicts
• Different state tax rates affect optimal distribution strategies

Annual Review and Long-Term Maintenance

Creating a Review Schedule

Set up an annual review process to keep your beneficiary designations current:

January Review Tasks:

• [ ] Verify all account balances and beneficiary percentages
• [ ] Update contact information if you've moved
• [ ] Review family changes from the previous year
• [ ] Check for any account changes or new products

After Major Life Events:

• Birth or adoption of children/grandchildren
• Death of family members
• Marriage or divorce (yours or your beneficiaries')
• Significant changes in family relationships
• Major changes in account balances or new accounts

Professional Consultation Timing

Consider consulting with professionals when:

Estate Planning Attorney:

• Your total estate exceeds $1 million
• You have complex family situations
• You're considering trust structures
• State law changes affect your planning

Financial Advisor:

• You need help coordinating multiple accounts
• Tax planning becomes complex
• You want to model different scenarios
• Retirement income planning intersects with estate planning

Tax Professional:

• Your estate may face generation-skipping taxes
• You live in a state with inheritance taxes
• Roth conversion strategies affect your planning

The decision between per stirpes and per capita isn't just about legal terminology—it's about ensuring your family's financial security matches your values and intentions. Take time to understand your options, review your current designations, and make informed choices that will protect your family's future for generations to come.

👉 If you would like to get a FREE retirement assessment, click the link to schedule your 20-minute call to start the retirement assessment process.