How Sequence of Return Risk Impacts Your Retirement

When planning for retirement, most of us focus on saving diligently and investing wisely. We track our portfolio growth, calculate our expected returns, and dream of the day we can finally relax and enjoy the fruits of our labor.

But there's a hidden risk lurking in the shadows of retirement planning that can derail even the most carefully crafted strategies: sequence of return risk. Sequence risk, also known as sequence of returns risk, is a critical factor that every soon-to-be retiree and current retiree needs to understand.

It's not just about how much you save or your average investment returns; it's about when those returns occur in relation to your retirement date. This timing can make or break your retirement plans, affecting your lifestyle, financial security, and peace of mind for years to come.

Even well-prepared retirees with substantial nest eggs can find themselves in hot water if they face poor market conditions in the early years of retirement.

Key Takeaways

• Sequence of return risk can significantly impact your retirement savings, especially in the early years of retirement.
• Diversification across asset classes and income sources is crucial for mitigating sequence risk.
• Maintaining a cash buffer can provide flexibility during market downturns.
• Flexible withdrawal strategies can help preserve capital during poor market conditions.
• Regular portfolio reviews and adjustments are essential for long-term retirement success.
• Professional guidance can provide valuable expertise in navigating the complexities of retirement planning.

WHAT IS SEQUENCE OF RETURN RISK?

Definition of Sequence Risk

Sequence of return risk refers to the potential for negative investment returns in the early years of retirement to have a disproportionate impact on the overall sustainability of your retirement portfolio. In simpler terms, it's the risk that the order in which you experience investment returns can significantly affect how long your money lasts in retirement.

This concept might seem counterintuitive at first. After all, if you're looking at long-term average returns, shouldn't the order of those returns be irrelevant? Not quite. The key difference lies in understanding that average returns don't tell the whole story when you're withdrawing money from your portfolio.

Why Timing Matters in Retirement

During your working years, when you're in the accumulation phase of your financial journey, the sequence of returns doesn't matter as much. You're consistently adding money to your investments, and market downturns can even be seen as opportunities to buy more shares at lower prices.

However, everything changes when you enter the decumulation phase in retirement. Now, you're no longer adding to your portfolio; instead, you're withdrawing funds to support your lifestyle. If you experience poor returns early in retirement, you're forced to sell more shares to meet your income needs, leaving fewer shares to recover when the market bounces back.

This dynamic creates a double whammy effect:

• Your portfolio value decreases due to poor market performance.
• You're selling more shares at lower prices, further depleting your portfolio.

The result? A potentially irreversible decline in your retirement savings that can jeopardize your long-term financial security.

THE MECHANICS OF SEQUENCE RISK

How Sequence Risk Affects Your Retirement Portfolio

To truly grasp the impact of sequence risk, let's dive into how it works in practice. Imagine two retirees, Alice and Bob, who both start with $1 million in their retirement accounts and plan to withdraw $40,000 annually (adjusted for inflation).

Alice retires in a year when the market performs well, experiencing positive returns in the first few years of her retirement. Bob, on the other hand, retires just before a market downturn, facing negative returns early on.

Here's how their scenarios might play out:

Alice's Retirement:

• Year 1: +7% return, portfolio grows to $1,030,000 after withdrawal
• Year 2: +5% return, portfolio at $1,041,500 after withdrawal
• Year 3: +6% return, portfolio at $1,063,990 after withdrawal

Bob's Retirement:

• Year 1: -5% return, portfolio drops to $910,000 after withdrawal
• Year 2: -3% return, portfolio at $842,700 after withdrawal
• Year 3: +2% return, portfolio at $819,554 after withdrawal

After just three years, the difference in their portfolio values is stark. Alice's portfolio has grown, while Bob's has shrunk significantly. This illustration demonstrates how the sequence of returns, especially in the early years of retirement, can have a profound impact on the longevity of your retirement savings.

The Critical Early Years of Retirement

Financial experts often refer to the five to ten years before and after your retirement date as the "retirement red zone." This period is crucial because your portfolio is at its largest, making it particularly vulnerable to market volatility.

Negative returns during this time can have a lasting impact on your retirement income for several reasons:

• Larger withdrawals: Poor returns mean you need to sell more shares to meet your income needs.
• Less time to recover: As you age, you have fewer years for your portfolio to bounce back from losses.
• Missed growth opportunities: Money withdrawn early in retirement misses out on potential compound growth over time.

Understanding this vulnerability is key to developing strategies that can help protect your retirement from sequence risk.

Real-World Implications of Sequence Risk

Impact on Retirement Lifestyle

The effects of sequence risk aren't just numbers on a page; they can have real and lasting impacts on your retirement lifestyle. Retirees facing poor returns early in retirement might find themselves forced to make difficult decisions:

• Reducing discretionary spending on travel, hobbies, or entertainment
• Cutting back on gifts to family or charitable donations
• Downsizing their home or relocating to a less expensive area
• Returning to part-time work to supplement their income

These adjustments can be more than just financial inconveniences; they can significantly alter the retirement experience you've spent years planning and saving for.

The Psychological Toll on Retirees

Beyond the practical implications, sequence risk can take a substantial emotional toll on retirees. The stress and anxiety of watching your hard-earned savings dwindle faster than anticipated can be overwhelming. This financial strain can lead to:

• Increased worry about running out of money
• Strained relationships with spouses or family members
• Feelings of guilt or failure, despite years of careful planning
• Reluctance to spend money, even on necessities, out of fear

It's important to recognize these psychological impacts and address them proactively, both in financial planning and in maintaining overall well-being during retirement.

Effects on Family Dynamics

The ripple effects of sequence risk can extend beyond the retiree to impact entire families. Adult children may find themselves in the unexpected position of providing financial support to their parents. This role reversal can lead to:

• Tension in family relationships
• Delayed milestones for younger generations (e.g., buying a home, starting a family)
• Changes in inheritance expectations
• Difficult conversations about money and care responsibilities

Open communication and proactive planning can help mitigate these challenges and preserve family harmony in the face of financial setbacks.

HOW SEQUENCE RISK AFFECTS DIFFERENT ASSET CLASSES

Understanding how sequence risk interacts with various asset classes is crucial for building a resilient retirement portfolio. Let's explore the unique considerations for different types of investments:

Equities and Sequence Risk

Stocks are often the growth engine of retirement portfolios, but they're also the most volatile asset class. This volatility can amplify sequence risk in several ways:

• Market declines: Sharp drops in stock prices can force retirees to sell more shares to meet income needs, depleting their portfolios faster.
• Recovery time: While stocks tend to recover over time, retirees may not have the luxury of waiting out long bear markets.
• Dividend cuts: Companies may reduce or eliminate dividends during economic downturns, further impacting income streams.

Strategy Tip: Consider gradually reducing equity exposure as you approach retirement, then slowly increasing it in later years to balance growth potential with risk management.

Fixed-Income Investments

Bonds are typically seen as a more stable counterpart to stocks, but they're not immune to sequence risk:

• Interest rate sensitivity: Rising interest rates can lead to capital losses in bond portfolios.
• Credit risk: Economic downturns can increase the risk of defaults, particularly in corporate bonds.
• Inflation risk: Low yields may not keep pace with inflation, eroding purchasing power over time.

Balancing act: While bonds can provide stability, an over-reliance on fixed income in early retirement could limit growth potential and increase longevity risk.

Cash and Cash Equivalents

Cash holdings can serve as a buffer against sequence risk:

• Stability: Cash doesn't fluctuate in value with market conditions.
• Liquidity: Easily accessible for withdrawals without selling assets at a loss.

However, cash comes with its own drawbacks:

• Low returns: Cash typically offers the lowest long-term returns among asset classes.
• Inflation risk: The purchasing power of cash erodes over time due to inflation.

Real Estate Investments

Real estate can offer diversification benefits and potential income streams, but it's not without risks:

• Market fluctuations: Property values can decline, especially during economic downturns.
• Liquidity concerns: Real estate can be difficult to sell quickly if cash is needed.
• Ongoing costs: Maintenance, property taxes, and insurance can strain retirement budgets.

Alternative Investments

Alternative investments like hedge funds, private equity, or commodities can offer diversification benefits but may also introduce additional risks:

• Complexity: These investments often require specialized knowledge to manage effectively.
• Liquidity risk: Many alternative investments have lock-up periods or limited redemption options.
• Higher fees: Management and performance fees can eat into returns.

STRATEGIES TO MITIGATE SEQUENCE OF RETURN RISK

Now that we've explored the ins and outs of sequence risk, let's dive into practical strategies to help protect your retirement from its potential impacts:

Build a Cash Buffer

One of the most straightforward ways to mitigate sequence risk is to maintain a sizable cash reserve:

• Recommendation: Aim for 2-3 years of living expenses in cash or cash equivalents.
• Purpose: This buffer allows you to avoid selling assets during market downturns.
• Implementation: Consider high-yield savings accounts or short-term bond funds for slightly better returns than traditional savings accounts.

Implement a Bucket Strategy

The bucket strategy involves dividing your portfolio into different "buckets" based on when you'll need the money:

• Short-term bucket: Cash and cash equivalents for immediate needs (1-2 years)
• Medium-term bucket: Conservative investments for 3-10 years out
• Long-term bucket: Growth-oriented investments for 10+ years in the future

This approach allows you to match investment risk with your withdrawal timeline, reducing the impact of short-term market volatility on your immediate income needs.

Practice Flexible Withdrawal Strategies

Rather than sticking to a fixed withdrawal amount, consider adjusting your withdrawals based on market performance:

• Reduce withdrawals during market downturns to preserve capital
• Increase withdrawals during strong market years to enjoy the upside

One popular method is the "guardrail approach," which sets upper and lower limits on withdrawals based on portfolio performance.

Diversify Income Sources

Don't rely solely on your investment portfolio for retirement income. Consider cultivating multiple income streams:

• Social Security benefits
• Pension payments (if available)
• Part-time work or consulting
• Rental income from real estate
• Annuities for guaranteed income

Diversifying your income sources can reduce the pressure on your investment portfolio during market downturns.

Maintain a Diversified Portfolio

While diversification doesn't eliminate sequence risk, it can help mitigate its impact:

• Spread risk across different asset classes, sectors, and geographic regions
• Rebalance regularly to maintain your target asset allocation
• Consider non-correlated assets that may perform differently in various market conditions

Consider a Rising Equity Glide Path

Contrary to traditional advice of decreasing equity exposure in retirement, some experts suggest a "rising equity glide path":

• Start retirement with a more conservative allocation
• Gradually increase equity exposure over time

This approach can help protect against sequence risk in the critical early years while allowing for growth potential later in retirement.

Regular Portfolio Reviews and Adjustments

Your retirement plan shouldn't be set in stone. Regular reviews and adjustments are crucial:

• Annual check-ups: Review your portfolio performance and withdrawal rate
• Life changes: Adjust your strategy in response to major life events
• Market conditions: Be prepared to adapt to changing economic environments

THE ROLE OF PROFESSIONAL GUIDANCE

While DIY retirement planning is possible, the complexities of sequence risk underscore the value of professional financial advice:

Benefits of Consulting a Financial Advisor

• Expertise: Advisors stay up-to-date on the latest strategies and research
• Objectivity: They can provide an unemotional perspective during market turbulence
• Comprehensive planning: Advisors consider your entire financial picture, not just investments
• Behavioral coaching: They can help you avoid common pitfalls and stick to your plan

Personalized Retirement Planning

A financial advisor can help tailor strategies to your unique situation, considering factors like:

• Your risk tolerance and investment goals
• Your health and family longevity
• Your desired lifestyle in retirement
• Your estate planning wishes

Remember, what works for one retiree may not be the best approach for another. Professional guidance can help you navigate these complex decisions with confidence.

FREQENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

Q: How does sequence risk differ from market volatility?

A: While both involve market fluctuations, sequence risk specifically refers to the impact of the order of returns on retirement withdrawals. Market volatility affects all investors, but sequence risk is particularly relevant to retirees who are withdrawing funds.

Q: Can sequence risk affect my pension?

A: Traditional defined-benefit pensions are generally not affected by sequence risk, as the payments are guaranteed by the pension provider. However, defined-contribution plans like 401(k)s are subject to sequence risk.

Q: Is it possible to eliminate sequence risk completely?

A: While it's not possible to eliminate sequence risk entirely, you can significantly mitigate its impact through careful planning and diversification strategies. The goal is to manage and reduce risk, not eliminate it completely.

Q: How often should I adjust my portfolio?

A: Regular reviews are important, but avoid making knee-jerk reactions to short-term market movements. An annual review is a good starting point, with additional check-ins during significant market events or life changes.

By understanding sequence risk and implementing strategies to mitigate its impact, you can increase the resilience of your retirement plan and enjoy greater financial security in your later years. Remember, retirement planning is an ongoing process, not a one-time event. Stay informed, be flexible, and don't hesitate to seek professional advice when needed. Your future self will thank you for the careful planning and consideration you put into managing sequence risk today.

👉 If you would like to get a FREE retirement assessment, click the link to schedule your 20-minute call to start the retirement assessment process.